John McDonnell MP: Another World Is Possible

Monday, July 28, 2008

Sorry but Warwick 2 will not be Enough to Save Labour

I read Jackie Ashley's column in the Guardian this morning and couldn't find the apology anywhere.

Only twelve months ago she headed up the media dinner party circuit that urged upon the Labour party the strategy of "the smooth transfer of power" from Blair to Brown. Ms. Ashley and vitually all the other media commentators arrogantly dismissed a leadership election enabling ordinary party members to engage in an honest political debate about the future of Labour as just a distraction.

This morning she urges the party to dump Gordon Brown and states that "the party desperately needs a debate about its future direction."

Just as Ms. Ashley and other media commentators were part of the process last year of preventing party members having a say over the leadership of the party now their articles over the last few days are already trying to limit that debate and limit the participants in the debate.

Already elements in the media have selected for us ordinary party members and trade unionists who will be on the shortlist for any future leadership election. The range of potential candidates has already been restricted by these media commentators to those, who like them, supported Gordon Brown and the thrust of New Labour policies over the last decade. The media is reducing the most important debate about Labour's future into the equivalent of a political fashion show catwalk for the sole enjoyment of the gliterati of central London.

What this fails to appreciate is that the vast majority of party members understand that it is a radical change of politics that is needed and not just a new face. Labour Party members must not allow the debate about the future of our party to be dictated by the small clique of media commentators.

That is why the discussion of Warwick 2 is critical. From what we now know about this weekend's agreement, Warwick 2 may contain some very limited advances in the preparation of a policy agenda that could limit the damage to our party at the next election but it is equally clear that it does not go anywhere near enough. Indeed in some areas such as the endorsement of the Government's reactionary welfare reform programme and support for academies it is a retrograde step towards the loss of even more of our supporters.

Over the coming months in the run up to the LRC's confrence in November my role will be to promote a rank and file discussion about the future political direction of the Labour party. This will be led by members not the media. If that discussion leads us to the conclusion that the debate about the future of our party should include a change of leader that that decision will not be determined by media commentators but by ordinary members of our party and our trade union supporters.

posted by John at 10:35 AM | permalink |

18 Comments:

Blogger Duncan Hall said...

This is definitely the right strategy, John. I would, of course, be an enthusiastic support for John4Leader 08, 09 or 10, but we should maintain a dignified distance from the current unedifying spectacle of personality politics being played out in the media.

I do now think that we are probably in a place where a) there can be no great change in direction without a change in personnel and b) there could be a leadership election whether we start it or not. But, be that as it may, a contest should be activist-led (unless a leadership election comes before then, started by the actions of others - in which case I assume you will be ready to bear the burden for us once again).

4:26 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The unions must use their influence to get a change of policy back to working class policies and socialism. How the General Secretaries must now regret their support for Brown - there won't be any change of policy without change of leader - but the parliamentary party is stuffed with fools, rogues and robots - they not only have no socialist prionciples but most also have no brain - picked for loyalty to the machine over anything else. Good luck John - you'll need it!!
Andy
Unite rep in NHS

12:14 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The Guardian is so behind the times - they're just catching up with Obama after finally letting go of Clinton's bid and the same with the UK leadership issue. That's why you have to read The Mirror as well as a "quality" (so-called!) newspaper.(Independent quite good on detail but still too right wing for me at times!) to find out what many ordianary people are thinking (It's not that I agree with all The Mirror does but it's cuts ot teh chase on politics,great for teh time-poor and balances the Guardina's perspective; it has has a great anti-smoking stance and parenting/healthy eatin pages though the problmen page woman is rather sexist towards wome I find an dthre's still too much emphasis on women's slimness etc etc but compared to Th eSun it's brillinat , it even had a whole page on things yo can do to boycott Zimbawean products and it always covers important things like Martin Luther King's legacy or something similar.. Sunday Mirror not as good though, still pretty tacky in places and Sat falls down anbit..but tabloids are what you will alwyas see being read in your workplace canteens/builders vans etc etc etc, not just The Guardian!

We have nothing to lose on the left if we do a leadrship bid. No-one villifies the right-wing of the Conservative party for doing what they wan tso whey shodl we be treated as pariahs? We wil have to deal with the fact that the press think that Jon Cruddas is a possible cnadidate if only with an "ouside chance" but mnay in the party have cottoned on to the fac that eh is a "phoney" politically as my ward chair put it, James Purnell dosen't cut the mustard and Miliband dosen't live in the real world - he neglected to bring wellies for himself adn his entourage while visiting an agricultural college recently....!(to take one small mischevious example!) an dif it was Straw etc we would also go ot sleep or die of boredom - no offence but we need to raise our game with our next leader... a mad telegraph jouro on BBC News 24 has just compared teh Camerons to John and Jacqueline Kennedy purely on the strength of them wearing trendier outfits than Gordon on their holidays...! - the Tories are obviously desparate for cameron to be seen as the British Obama - dream on Tories !
we do need to start NOW and I have alrady recieved an email relevan tto this as leaving ot to another conference entirely run by Brown's machine will miss the boat by years. I think obama's strenght is tha thw knows when to go on to teh next stage in Politics without regretsor too much self-doubt (or he wouldn't have run against Clinton) but he is firmly in touch with his grass roots and most importantly the real world in general and he has the perspective to remain positive - 9I think Cameron would soon start whinging and blaming others if the tide turned against him like most Tories!). These strenghts of positivity while remaining grounded and good leadership are what I see in John, who has I think just teh right amoun tof experince for teh job - not too much or too little - coupled with a very human ability to drive people sligthly up the wall sometimes for something minor such as saying he would return to his constituency in Hayes and be don ewith natiomal politics as he would probably lose his seat at teh next election teh way things were going....It was salong meeting with many wanting to contribut so I didnt get a chance to join in o this topic as they had made teh fatal mistake of leavin gthe poitical discussion to teh end so everyone sits there burstin gto sound off and so the yall try at once..so I'l say what i woudl have said now i..e
John as Barry Obama woudl say your're no tgoing to lose your seat "ANYTIME SOON!". But we need to raise expectations agian and yo an go further so tha twe can all do better. We must make one big attempt at getting teh British peopel to pull back from teh brink of the Tory abyss -if not it will be five years ahenad after opposiiton...

leaving typos as too late and my cat is trying to sleep!

Helen Ingram

1:14 AM 
Anonymous Dirty Euro: said...

What about the millions of lives the PM has saved in Africa. That was left wing. And it hardly won him any votes in Henley with thoese BNP voting scum bags. So he did have some guts to do great stuff.
I know this is controversial thing to say but i wonder if glasghow east is the PM's backyard It is a Irish - catholic scottish seat he scottish proddie. The seat surprisingliy has a large ammouint of support for independende as high 50 %. So this was not the back yard seat people thought it was. A scottish proddie might be as alien to the seat as an english man.

11:37 AM 
Anonymous Will said...

Well said Duncan. John - don't be pressured by attention seekers trying to ride on the back of your candidacy. You played it exactly right last time - the movement called on you to stand, and you ran a great campaign. However, the forces were too great against us - and I'm not sure what's changed since.

I hope you do get on the ballot paper for any future contest and I would back you, but unless that's very likely, just concentrate on representing the movement in Parliament, on the picket lines and in protests - don't waste your time trying to be leader of that shower.

2:37 PM 
Blogger Jon Rogers said...

John,

there will be a leadership contest (though you rightly will not call for it)

when there is you have to run

it's obvious

we need a socialist candidate in such an election if we are to organise for socialist policies within the Party

if you try you may fail

if you don't try you fail every time

good luck!

10:50 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I agree with jon rogers 100%. John, your leadership bid last time round was exciting and bold. What must be true now is that out of all New Labour M.P.'s, John has got at least the greatest know how in running a leadership campaign. (can't be sure as to who is still around from the Blair campaign).Granted, that doesn't guarantee success against the crawling,waste of spacers but it's a decent enough platform. I wonder what our enlightened trade union leaders would do this time? I'm sure we all learned alot from last time. Therefore, should a leadership battlecome your way again, then carpe diem and we'll all do what we can, whether from inside the party or, quite likely, from without.

9:47 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Buy Accutane Online.Cheap Accutane
Buy Soma Online.Order Soma.Cheap Soma
Buy Generic Lasix.Buy Lasix Online
Buy Lipitor online.Generic Lipitor Cheap
Buy Prozac Online.Buy Generic Prozac.Order Prozac
BUY CHEAP SEROQUEL ONLINE! ORDER SEROQUEL ONLINE

12:43 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Order Xanax no prescription.Cheap Xanax Online
Buy Oxycontin Online.Order Oxycontin overseas
Buy Percocet Online.Percocet without prescription
Buy Elavil without prescription.Buy Elavil On-line
Extra cheap Phentermine.Cheap 37 5 phentermine

1:23 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Photoshop CS4
Windows XP
cheap jordan shoes
Microsoft Office
Metallic UGG Boots
Mini UGG Boots

10:27 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

池袋 風俗
渋谷 風俗
新宿 風俗
性病検査
大人のおもちゃ
アダルトDVD
av 写真
大人のおもちゃ
アダルトグッズ
アダルトグッズ
アダルト ブルーレイ
アダルトショップ
ペニス増大
電マ
TENGA
SM 通販
メンズセクシー下着
男性用下着
Tバック下着
大規模修繕 工事
決済代行
SEO
SEO
花植物大図鑑
決済代行
不倫調査
尾行調査
企業調査
身元調査
身辺調査
結婚調査
夫の浮気
妻の浮気
尾行調査
企業調査
所在調査
身辺調査
追跡調査
尾行調査
ストーカー調査
浮気調査
身元調査
信用調査
浮気調査
身辺調査
信用調査
特殊調査
所在調査
素行調査
追跡調査
信用調査
身上調査
所在調査
ストーカー調査
妻の浮気
ストーカー調査
素行調査
盗聴調査
身元調査
不倫調査
探偵
不倫調査
妻浮気
結婚調査
信用調査
データ調査
不倫調査
夫婦浮気
身元調査
盗聴調査

4:42 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Breitling Watches
Cartier Watches
Omega Watches
Tag Heuer Watches
Panerai Watches
IWC Watches
Patek Philippe Watches
Chopard Watches
Gucci Watches
Bell & Ross Watches

Breitling Watches
Burberry Watch
Chopard Watches
Concord Watch
Omega Watch
Burberry
Breitling
Chopard
Concord
Omega

Omega Replicas
Cartier Replicas
Replica Marc Jacobs
Replica Cartier Watches
Cartier Watches Wholesale
Omega Watches Wholesale
Cartier Watch Replicas
Marc Jacobs Bags
Cheap Replica Watches
Cartier Watches Wholesale

Watches For Sale
Fashion Watches
Wholesale Replica Watches
Cartier Replica
Replica Designer Handbags
Cheap Designer Handbags
Discounted Handbags
Omega Replica
Cartier Replicas
Replica Cartier Watches
Marc Jacobs Replica Handbags

3:11 AM 
Blogger ED Hardy Mens Underwear said...

First of all, we should love links of london charms our motherland. Let’s take a great links of london charm interest in the development of our links of london Sweetie Bracelets hometowns and take an active part in our school and activities.
Secondly, let’s fill the world links london Sweetie Braceletwith love. We should show our respect links london Bracelet for old people, our parents and our teachers. We should also care for each links of london Bracelets other and help those in need. More importantly, all links of london Necklaces of us must be faithful and honest in our daily life.
Finally, let’s links london Necklace work together to save energy and protect our natural environment, including animals, trees, flowers and grass.
As for myself, I will study links of london friendship bracelets even harder and try my best to do all the above.
Dear fellow students, let’s start links london friendship bracelet fight now and spare no effort/efforts to do a links of london Sweetie Watches little bit every day, every hour, and every minute!

4:24 AM 
Anonymous ugg boots sale said...

I agree with you, your saying is so good and usful for me. Thanks. Are you also like
ugg boots sale
ugg australia
uggs
It’s a meaningful and interesting topic. Thanks.

1:49 AM 
Anonymous ugg boots said...

Paragraph star UGG boots, many shops Amoy’s that some people go online to buy or Shopping Service, in a word, they are
very good look, take a look at the stars with their own, become a star is a small case! This the reason why
ugg boots sale are so popular now!Put on cotton boots is also moving up and
quiet,such as the ugg boots uk match with the pants.there is also a good dress with Miu leather. At the same time, necessary are gloves, ear muffs, snow ugg boots, sunglasses, scarf and so on, which you can pick the beautiful pieces of dress, no matter how technology, let us heavily armed first.so
now ugg boots sale in many shoes shop.there are many ugg boots you can choose in the
ugg boots uk shop!

3:15 AM 
Blogger Edwin said...

Buy Kamagra
Earn Google
M65 Jacket
Viagra Cialis
Cheap Kamagra
Cheap Viagra
Cheap Cialis
Make Money on Google
M65 Field Jacket
Airline Dog Carrier
Airline Dog Carriers
Viagra Cialis
Earn Google
Airline Dog Carrier
Airline Dog Carriers
Airline Approved Dog Carriers
ED Hardy Wholesale
Copy DVD Software
How to Send Fax
14k Yellow Gold
Redneck Costume
14k Gold Heart
Tandem Baby Stroller

12:34 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

glasses
eyeglasses frams
prescription sunglasses
cheap glasses

sports eyeglasses
eyeglass frames
eyeglasses

girls eyeglasses
women eyeglasses

children eyeglasses
kids glasses
cheap kids glasses

progressive glasses
progressive eyeglasses
progressive eyeglasses online
progressive lens

7:41 AM 
Anonymous ugg Bailey Button said...

0208sllrk The only word of Ashley is that he was in a Yankee prison for the last year of ugg classic cardy boots the war and a letter to Melanie telling her that he is on his way. One day, ugg Bailey Button he appears coming up the long road towards Tara. Melanie and Scarlett both rush to greet him, but Will stops Scarlett, ugg classic short boots saying, "Don't ruin the moment." ugg classic mini boots Scarlett reluctantly hangs back,ugg new arrival but is euphoric over Ashley's return.

2:19 AM 

Post a Comment

<< Home