John McDonnell MP: Another World Is Possible

Sunday, August 03, 2008

An Appeal for Calm and a Bit of Common Sense and Decency.

This morning the media is again full of plotters engaged in the planning of coups and counter coups, conspirators infighting and character assassination. It's just another day in the life of New Labour.

The Blairite New Labour spin machine has gone into overdrive in promoting David Miliband throughout their usual media outlets. Yesterday it was embarrassing to read exactly the same eulogies to Miliband from the likes of the Guardian's Polly Toynbee that she had written initially for Tony Blair and only 12 months ago for Gordon Brown. Now in the Sunday papers we have Blair's own revenge attack on Brown published.

Also today the Jon Cruddas and Neal Lawson Compass camp has launched its leadership bid with a very personal coded attack on David Miliband, accusing him of a "narcissistic cash for personal glory" and refers to his small faction that "seeks immaturely to gain advantage." Whilst they call for policy changes and list a few policies the Government should consider, the only slight problem is that over the last 11 years they have wholeheartedly supported the Government's policies they now criticise and voted against many of the policies they now advocate.

The Brownite response is a planned cabinet reshuffle to bring more unquestioning supporters into the cabinet. This just gives even further the impression of a beleagured leader defensively circling of the wagons. Just at a time when we need more open and honest debate in cabinet he appears to be stifling this opportunity.

In the long term interests of our party, the people we seek to represent and indeed the country, we desperately need to find a way out of this mess and to end the personal dogfighting and to help restore some dignity to the standing of the Labour Party and our Government.

My straightforward proposal is that we should impose a time limit on the debate on whether there is to be a leadership election or not. This would involve saying to all these various contenders that by the Labour party conference in September you should declare whether you wish to stand for leader of our party. If you wish to stand then say so and publish the policy manifesto upon which you want to invite support from our members. So that there can be no means by which the factions within the Parliamentary Labour party can block an election we should drop the rule which a a candidate must secure a minimum number of MPs' nominations and thus veto an election.

At least this process force the current prospective candidates to make their minds up and come out the dark. It should not prevent any future debate about the policies Labour should pursue but at least it would no longer place these proper and democratic debates in the context of leadership conspiracies.

I appeal to all those who have participated in the discussion about Labour's future to support this compromise plan to resolve the current impasse.

posted by John at 11:03 AM | permalink |

23 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

we must have a democratic election - at least in teh Us they have primaries - this tiem or we will be a laughing stock and we will lose (even more) respect internationally- we need to follow the US into a new kind of politics now..

12:47 PM 
Anonymous c r said...

John, as a party member I totally support your line of thinking. The various factions and power-plays are leading to a point where only the Tories will benefit from the public's take on a what can be seen as a wriggling sack of worms.

More than ever we need to look at reconstituting the Party - entrench the differences between leading the party and leading the PLP - and make the former the senior figure in regards to policy.

6:55 PM 
Blogger Shropshire Progressive said...

It's a crying shame that 44 Labour MPs could not be found to support John's original quest for Labour leader. What is needed is an open debate to highlight the failings of new labour and to push for more progressive/radical policies. The world is crying out for decent socialist policies to create a fairer more equitable system which places people before the profits of the multinationals and leads us away from the death and destruction that has been wrought on regions of the world by the corrupt system we have a the moment

9:24 PM 
Anonymous ifweworkers said...

The problem with Britis democracy is that the deciding of policy by the electorate is secondary to the election of the men (it's mainly men) who do the deciding.

12:52 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The Blairites (who dont seem to realsie they have no support0 are trying to organise a crisis now so they can have a big walk out and claim that a labour defeat at the election had nothing to do with their policies.

the truth is we were always going to have an election next year brown was always going to have to stand down

the truth is we need a much "Broader" left supporting john this time
and this means talking to ALL trade union leaders, even the ones we may disagree with not trying to get small unelected unrepresentative groups in these unions to get around it...it simply wont work

11:22 PM 
Blogger Derek Wall said...

If I back you, it would be like Castro backing Obama.

Although unlike Obama you have a solid set of socialist demands and it would be great to see them discussed.

11:39 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Are you officialy launching the leadership bid.. don't always hear Today due to being a night owl and not liking talk progs at that time but you are on The Sun website of all places...! I only went on there to follow up a biographical link of Obama's Irish relations...
you can get the schedule for teh Democratic conv on CNN Politics (see The Situation Roon, Jack Cafferty etc) - Obama to speak on the Thurs tho there is goin gto be anomination thing with Hillary, also Bill, Hillary, V-p, Michelle Obama and I think ted Kennedy...after all that lot maybe peole her in the UK will be able to focus on our leadership issues. cameron thinks he is new Obama and need to be pu tdown (politcaly not literally1) - we shd have time if no election for 18m and we can campaign for a democratic lelection this time and have time for people to ge tto know John as candidate. We need to expose(as part of our J4l'08 campaign) things such as the fact that Labour wouldn't debate Iraq, teh arcane rules that require topics like that to be put on the agenda a year in advance...my husband couldn't belive that Labour still operates like this in this day and age!.. new Obam aattack bnook all lies of course -just read Dreans From My Father..see Amazon (though baddies union -busters_ for a preview of his policy book which is coming out , think called Change we can belive in...happy holidays to you all....maybe Obam anot asociliast but speaks up fo rfathers and undertands racial issues, has dileemas as multi-racila, at least he will talk to Iran etc unlie McCain..on Afghnaistan he has to talk tough cos of 9-11,, I don't know, I'd like pacifism bu tthe Taliban endorse torture (at work I had an Afghan surgeon cliam asylum to me as Taliban had wanted him to strat cuttinng people's hands off etc adn he wouildn't so he left his family to claim asylum and I think he was on for gettin it though that decision was made in another department - he would have been made a recognised refugee so they're not all econominc migrants and anywya I'd try it if I lived in a poor country, wouldn't we all..?) and as with many other regime in the world their treatment of women has got to stop..

2:49 AM 
Blogger Harry Barnes said...

John,

I hope that you will pursue this one -
http://threescoreyearsandten.blogspot.com/2008/08/defend-iranian-democrats.html

Harry Barnes

3:36 PM 
Anonymous Dirty Euro said...

I think Cruddas should be brought into the cabinet. I am more soft left to be honest. I was against the Iraq war but I do see we need to be electable. Cruddas is his own man and would be a good one to bring into the cabinet.

10:15 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

John why are you backing someone in the SWP who is on video smashing up his political opponents (AWL) meetings

6:34 PM 
Blogger Duncan Hall said...

What's this referring to?

7:18 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Happy Birthday to all you hard-working Virgo people!

Left need to improve our links with Howard Dean and co in the US who were in at the beginning of the grassroots regeneration building behind Obama.

Of course Obama can be criticized from the left though at least his voting record is pretty liberal but first let's focus on his economic policies currently being discussed in the US media this week. As to the religious issue - another issue they will soon cover in the election run-up hopefully those in doubt due to ignorance abou tteh Islamic faith in the US will realise that even if he was a Muslim this would almost certainly mean he is not an extremist in line with most Muslims! only 60 odd days to go to the elction so we need a strategy in place to increase our US links and see what we can learn from the obama "Change" campaign a.s.a.p.

12:30 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

there is a statement from obama on the Freddie Mac/Fannie Mae situation posted yesterday on the Obama for America website in which he states he wants to protect the jobs and homes of ordinary people not just line shareholders pockets.

12:48 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Buy Lunesta online.Cheap generic Lunesta
Order voltaren online. Generic voltaren
Purchase Lasix.Buy Lasix 40 mg
Buy Provera Online.Cheap Generic Provera
Buy Zyban Online.Cheap Zyban.Order Zyban

10:53 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Order Xenical.Cheap Xenical.Buy Xenical
Buy Acomplia Online.Acomplia Discount
Order Piroxicam. Buy Piroxicam Online
Purchase Flonase.Buy flonase generic
Buy Evista Online.Buy Generic Evista

10:54 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Breitling Watches
Cartier Watches
Omega Watches
Tag Heuer Watches
Panerai Watches
IWC Watches
Patek Philippe Watches
Chopard Watches
Gucci Watches
Bell & Ross Watches

Breitling Watches
Burberry Watch
Chopard Watches
Concord Watch
Omega Watch
Burberry
Breitling
Chopard
Concord
Omega

Omega Replicas
Cartier Replicas
Replica Marc Jacobs
Replica Cartier Watches
Cartier Watches Wholesale
Omega Watches Wholesale
Cartier Watch Replicas
Marc Jacobs Bags
Cheap Replica Watches
Cartier Watches Wholesale

Watches For Sale
Fashion Watches
Wholesale Replica Watches
Cartier Replica
Replica Designer Handbags
Cheap Designer Handbags
Discounted Handbags
Omega Replica
Cartier Replicas
Replica Cartier Watches
Marc Jacobs Replica Handbags

3:12 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

dicount replica handbags for sale
dicount replicas handbags for sale
dicount wholesale replica handbags for sale
dicount designer replica handbags for sale
dicount replica designer handbags for sale
dicount fake designer handbags for sale
dicount replica handbags wholesale for sale
dicount Gucci Handbags for sale
dicount replica louis vuitton handbags for sale
dicount bottega veneta replica handbags for sale
dicount burberry handbags for sale
dicount christian dior handbags for sale
dicount d & g handbags for sale
dicount fendi handbags for sale
dicount hermes handbags for sale
dicount hermes handbags discount for sale
dicount hermes replica handbags for sale
dicount jimmy choo handbags for sale
dicount tods handbags for sale
dicount marc jacobs handbags for sale
dicount thomas wylde handbags for sale
dicount miu miu handbags for sale
dicount mulberry handbags for sale
dicount gucci handbags for sale
dicount cartier handbags for sale
dicount chloe handbags for sale
dicount givenchy handbags for sale
cheap discount gucci handbags for sale
dicount wholesale gucci handbags for sale
dicount juicy couture handbags for sale
dicount loewe handbags for sale
dicount prada handbags for sale
dicount SalvatoreFerragamo Handbags for sale
dicount valentino handbags for sale
dicount versace handbags for sale

10:24 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Watcheslux.com provides high quality Swiss replica watches including Rolex replicas, replica Breitling replica watches, replica Omega watches and other replicas watches. We offer 24-hour online customer service and free express shipment worldwide, just come to have a look. Thank you.

6:43 AM 
Anonymous barbrine said...

Welcome to our website,http://www.progiftstore.com, we are professional watch maker who can provide you with a variety of replica watches, these replica watches are high quality and are sold at a cheap price.

12:03 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

cheap replica bags 2009 desinger handbags
buy replica handbags
jerseysnfl
nfl jerseys
official nfl jerseys
men's jerseys
campaign series
cheap ugg
short ugg shoes
buy ugg boots
tiffany watches
tiffany jewelry
nice jewelry
cheap tiffany
cheap tiffany jewelry
silver jewelry
replica jewel
ed hardy fashion
ed hardy handbag
buy ed hardy
2009 uggs
high grade sandals
ugg discount
ugg classic
wholesale shoe
replica tiffany
replica tiffany jewelry
cheap tiffany
wholesale replica jewelry
Rings
Earrings
Necklaces
pink ugg
cheap ugg
short ugg
ugg boots
replica watches
cheap luxury watches
fake watches
replica watch
rolex watch
wholesale replica watches
mens watches
FREE shoping
cheap watches

8:19 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

fashion tiffany jewelry
buy cheap jewelry
designer tiffany jewelry
cheap jewelry

tiffany jewelry
silver bracelets
tiffany bangles
buy tiffany jewelry

timberland boots
classic timberland
timberland shoes online
cheap timberland

nike air max
af1 shoes
nike jordan
nike shox

ugg boots
ugg discount
cheap ugg classic


ugg boots
fashion ugg
cheap ugg shoes
ugg discount

buy ipod touch
mp4 mp5 players
discount ipods touch

footwear
gucci shoes
bape shoes
boots shoes

Bose On Headphone
mp4 player
electricals kits
wholesale bose headphone

cheap jewelry
buy ipod touch
mp4 mp5 players
discount ipods touch

ugg shoes online
ugg chestnut
buy ugg boots
cheap ugg

4:35 AM 
Anonymous ugg boots said...

Paragraph star UGG boots, many shops Amoy’s that some people go online to buy or Shopping Service, in a word, they are
very good look, take a look at the stars with their own, become a star is a small case! This the reason why
ugg boots sale are so popular now!Put on cotton boots is also moving up and
quiet,such as the ugg boots uk match with the pants.there is also a good dress with Miu leather. At the same time, necessary are gloves, ear muffs, snow ugg boots, sunglasses, scarf and so on, which you can pick the beautiful pieces of dress, no matter how technology, let us heavily armed first.so
now ugg boots sale in many shoes shop.there are many ugg boots you can choose in the
ugg boots uk shop!

2:54 AM 
Blogger Edwin said...

Buy Kamagra
Earn Google
M65 Jacket
Viagra Cialis
Cheap Kamagra
Cheap Viagra
Cheap Cialis
Make Money on Google
M65 Field Jacket
Airline Dog Carrier
Airline Dog Carriers
Viagra Cialis
Earn Google
Airline Dog Carrier
Airline Dog Carriers
Airline Approved Dog Carriers
ED Hardy Wholesale
Copy DVD Software
How to Send Fax
14k Yellow Gold
Redneck Costume
14k Gold Heart
Tandem Baby Stroller

12:33 PM 

Post a Comment

<< Home