John McDonnell MP: Another World Is Possible

Monday, February 16, 2009

Bank Bonus Debate Exposes Political Bankruptcy

The Government's weak-kneed response over bank bonuses and nationalising the banks is pushing the Brown administration to the edge of crisis. People are demanding action and yet by prevaricating Gordon Brown is allowing the Tories opportunistically to take the high ground. The bank bonus debate has exposed the political bankruptcy of the leaderships of all the major parties.

Brown needs to stop faffing around and act fast to end the bonuses to the fat cats, and to take control by nationalising the banks. His credibility is draining fast and swift action is needed if this administration is to survive.

The bonus scandal has also exposed that whilst the fat cats on the Bank Boards have been lapping up the bonuses, many of their staff have been on low pay, dependent on the annual bonus shareout to top up their low salaries.

Each year for five years I have tabled motions in Parliament codemning the big city bonuses as obscene and calling for action with no response from the Government. People's patience with the Government is fast runing out. Decisive action now could turn this around.

posted by John at 1:28 PM | permalink |

46 Comments:

Anonymous Dirty Euro: said...

But if the banks are nationalised many ordinary people lose thousands of pounds in investments. I think part nationalisation is the only fair scheme. That way ordinary investors still have something left.

I think part nationalisation could be a new strategic model for large companies of national importance that way they get the benefits of run for their own good but with strategic overview from the government to ensure they do not take bad risks, pay insane fees to those at the top, and are looking after the interests of the nation.

The railways should be part nationalised. Full nationalisation means no one is there in the company supporting their interests.
The government should have a say over bonuses. But I feel full nationalisation would be very cruel to small shareholders, especially as the government told Lloyds to buy HBOS in the first place. Remember many people invested thousands of hard earned pounds in these banks they should not suffer for that. That would be cruel.
And if some people say well it was just a gamble, to invest in shares, why should the government care, well you can say that about pensions, poverty, houses, health service, schools, cars, the government does have an interest in looking after people and ensuring people do not lose all their savings and investment to ensure they do not fall into poverty. Especially small business men who have to make their own investments and do not have a lump sum from the government to rely on. Investments should be protected. Full nationalisation with no compensation would be ok for those no affected but nightmare for those who invest in banks.

2:13 PM 
Anonymous Dirty Euro: said...

Small investors should be protected they do not have big salaries.

2:14 PM 
Blogger Curlew said...

But also small savers should be protected, Dirty Euro.

At least when shares are sold there is a health warning that the value of shares can go up or down. It's up to the shareholder to keep an eye on their stock. And let's face it, many "ups" have been experienced in the last 15 years or so.

But for a savings account there is a "no risk" clause. So if necessary the banks should be nationalised to stops runs on it.

10:15 PM 
Anonymous Dirty Euro: said...

I dissagree. The government got lloyds to buy Hbos so they have no right to close down Lloyds and destroy the shares, whrn they Lloyds bank would have been OK otherwise.

I have never seen the no risk clause on a savings account.

Putting money in a savings is in reality as safe, when a bank collapses, as putting money in savings. There is no real difference. Savings in a bank that has collapsed is worth as much as the shares. It is only the government have decided they will protect small savers, but not small shareholders why? what is the difference? There is no legal reason why they should protect a small saver over a small shareholder, other than more voters have savings. That is not morality or law. And many millionaires have had their savings protected by nationalisation while middle or working class people will see their shares wiped out, so it is not class issue.
Plus no one invested in banks expecting a 500% profit for no work they just expected well run blue chip companies to hold a steady investment for when they retired. We are not talking up some high risk internet company, we're talking about banks, which are supposed to be well run.
Why do you expect small savers who put their money in HBOS to be protected but not small shareholders. The small shareholers are just the same people.

And if you say well it serves them right for making these risky investments, well you can say the same about savers, why not let the banks collapse and not give any small savers their money back if that is the attitude as obviously they should have known what derivatives trades, and bonus payments the COEs were doing at these banks using that logic.
Do you think small savers like pensioners and retirees should be punished for not knowing what funny trades the bosses of the banks were tolerating, or is it just the shareholders who are also often pensioners who should be punished for not knowing what trades the bank heads are doing.

4:26 PM 
Anonymous Dirty Euro: said...

I meant savings in a bank that has collapsed are as worthtless as shares. So why should savings be protected but not shares. There is no difference. You could argue a pensioners should have known what trades the bankers were up to, so it is their fault if they lose all their savings. That is a harsh attitude.
Why should middle class savers be protected so much that middle class shares holders lose everything.
There is no legal obligation on the government to compensate savers in any way at all. So why do you thin there is.

4:35 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

lets not forget that bankers bonuses and pay is purely symbolic in this case. they might be easy to attack but it doesn't actually do anything to help deal with the crisis, so it maybe isn't hard to see why parliament didn't take mcdonnell seriously.

yes, it should be done, but it still seems like 'outdated socialist blather' to bang on about it. there are bigger targets.

7:37 PM 
Anonymous Dirty Euro said...

I think bonuses are still important for those banks that have failed. They should not be given bonuses. Do not be bigotted against those from the left. Be open to ideas.

9:49 PM 
Anonymous Dirty Euro said...

But ordinary workers should be given bonuses if they deserve it even in failed banks. Just not those at the top.

9:50 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Just want to say John you're a real inspiration and if you suceed Gordon Brown I will must definitley vote labour once again. Please, for all our sakes keep up the good work!

11:18 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

we need to make a stand aginst New Labour who are guilty of sending peopel to torture in Guantamo Bay/Morroc etc

11:50 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

just been to An Audience With Tony Benn in High Wycombe - he did a clever show which convinced everyone from young socialist students to the typical Tory types you tend to get in Home County territory that war shoudl be outlawed and that there was hope for the world...see www.celecbrityproductions.info for the rest of his tour dates whihc are on adn off till November...go and see it!

11:28 PM 
Blogger Harry Barnes said...

Here are two more issues for the pot. Comments welcome -
http://dronfieldblather.blogspot.com/2009/02/our-submissions-to-compass.html

4:53 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The Government should nationalise failing banks without compensation, and use taxpayers money to protect savers, and people in danger of losing their homes and jobs.
Yes, it would be tough for shareholders, but people who play the stockmarket surely know that it's a risky game. Shareholders didn't complain when the banks were playing roulette, because they thought they were on a winning streak, but everyone knows gambling is a fools game.
Savers on the other hand put their money in the bank (rather than under the mattress), because they think a bank is more secure.
Also as an aside Brown needs to apologise, because he actively aided and encouraged the liberalisation/globalisation that has made our Country susceptible to this state of affairs.

7:39 PM 
Anonymous Dirty Euro said...

There is no difference between small savers and small shareholders at all. How is there any difference? How can a saver be given the excuse well it is not your fault that you did not know how well the bank was being run, but if exactly the same person puts the money in shares they should just have their entire investment take off them. There is no morality there. You could take all the savers money off them and claim it serves them right for not knowing how the bank is run. Not all savers are being saved just small savers small shareholders should also be compensated.
Investing in shares in not gambling, and never has been, you might as well claim pensions are gambling and tough luck if people lose their pensions.

Derivatives is gambling but shares, is investing in companies to build new industries.
Not all of us have government pensions provided for us. Most of us work in the private sector where we have to manage our own finances do not punish us for that.
Especilaly when the government asked for lloyds to buy up the HBOS, so it would be unacceptable to destroy the shares now. Investing in shares is not gambling. Just as pensions and investment in bank accounts are not gambling.

11:21 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

People playing the stock market are gambling with their money, frankly I have no sympathy whatsoever. They backed the wong horses and they have no more right to get hold of tax payers money than your average joe who lost his money at the bookies.

It is people who are forced on the dole because of these fat cats who need the help from tax payers.

11:19 AM 
Blogger Sixxstring90 said...

It is moronic to want to nationalise the banks. If the state took over these banks, whose balance sheets exploded because of Labour, they were in surplus under Thatcher and Major, they would be taking on trillions of bad assets in the public's name. John, get real, stop preaching socialism, it is a dead ideology that is economically impossible to accomplish. Capitalism works and it works fine

9:41 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Photoshop CS4
Windows XP
cheap jordan shoes
Microsoft Office
Metallic UGG Boots
Mini UGG Boots

10:22 AM 
Anonymous nike dunk said...

you may as well nike dunks read magazines concerning the nike dunks shoes job without worthless papers nike dunk sb on the desk,
please apprise of ugg boots Sale your decision to us to do corresponding operation for Uggs it.

8:20 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

If you can keep your head when all about youmetin2 yang.Are losing theirs and blaming it on you;metin2 yang If you can trust yourself when all men doubt you,metin2 yangmetin2 yangBut make allowance for their doubting too;aion kinahIf you can wait and not be tired by waiting,metin2 yang,aion kinah,aion kinahOr, being lied about,don't deal in lies,aion kinahOr,aion kinah being hated,aion kinah.on't give way to hating,aion kinah,wow goldmetin2 yangmetin2 yang And yet don't look too good, nor talk too wise; metin2 yangmetin2 yangmetin2 yang

3:28 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

If you can dream metin2 yang- and not make dreams your master;metin2 yang
If you can think metin2 yang- and not make thoughts your aim;metin2 yangmetin2 yang
If you can meet with triumph and disaster,metin2 yang
And treat thosemetin2 yang two impostors just the same;ffxi gilaion kinah
If you can bear to hear the truth you've spoken ffxi gil
Twiseted byffxi gil knaves to make a trap for fools,wow gold kaufenwow goldcomprar wow goldwow po
Or watch the things youbuy metin2 yang gave your life to broken,cheap metin2 yangbuy metin2 yang
And stoop and build 'em up with buy metin2 yangwornout tools;cheap metin2 yangbuy metin2 yangcheap metin2 yang

3:29 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Nails
Has a bad tempercheap metin2 yang of the boy, buy metin2 yangbuy metin2 yangcheap metin2 yanghis father gave him a bag of nails. cheap wow goldAnd told him thatbuy metin2 yangbuy metin2 yangcheap metin2 yangwow gold kaufenbuy ffxi gilfinal fantasy xi gil whenever he lost his temper aion kinahwhen a nail on the nail in the backyard on the fence. cheap maplestory mesosbuy aion kinahThe first day, buy wow goldthe boy has nailed 37 nails. Slowly, Lord Of The Rings Goldunder aion goldAion time cardAion powerlevelingmetin2 yang

3:29 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

It was New Year's Night. An aged man was standing at a window. power leveling metin2comprar yang de metin2He raised his mournful eyes towards the deep blue sky,metin2 fast levelingyang metin 2metin2comprar oro metin2metin2 shop where the stars weremetin2 yangkaufyang metin2yang metin2yang metin2 floating like white lilies on the surface of a clear calm lake. yang acheter metin2cheat metin2 yangsmetin2metin2 ItalyThen he cast them on the earth, wow gold KaufenAcheter WoW OrWoW Pobuy wow cdkeycd key wowcheap wow powerlevelingcheap powerlevelingcheap ffxi gil

3:30 AM 
Blogger hanyi said...

winter ugg boots

8:13 AM 
Blogger ED Hardy Mens Underwear said...

The report says ed hardy shoes lack of water in the future ed hardy hats may result in several problems. It may ed hardy jeans increase health problems. Lack of water often means drinking ed hardy belts waters not safe. Mr. Engelman says there are problems ed hardy kids all over the world because of diseases, such as ed hardy hoodies cholera, which are carried in water. Lack of water ed hardy caps may also result in more international conflict. Countries ed hardy bags may have to compete for water in the ed hardy purses future. Some countries now get ed hardy t shirts sixty percent of their fresh water from other countries. This ED Hardy Mens Hoodies is true of Egypt, the Netherlands, Cambodia, Syria, Sudan, and Iraq. And the report says lack ed hardy sunglasses of water would affect the ability of ED Hardy Swimwear developing to improve ED Hardy Swim Trunks their economies. This is because Ed Hardy Mens T-Shirt new industries often need a large ED Hardy Mens Tops amount of water when they are beginning.

2:42 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Glashutte Watches |
Gucci Watches |
Hermes Watches |
Iwc Watch |
Longines Watches |
Louis Vuitton Watches |
Link Watches |
Mont Blanc Watches |
Monaco Watches |
Mcrcedes-Benz Watches |
Armani Watches |
Ferrari Watches |
Omega Watches |
Patek Philippe Watches |
Porsche Watches |
Piaget Watches |
Roger Dubuis Watches |
Tag Heuer Watches |
Vacheron Constantin Watches |
Hublot Watches |
Tisssot Watches |
--------------------------------GLT09alili1204
Wholesale scarves |
Designer silk scarf |
Women's Scarves |
Fashion scarves |
Burberry Scarves |
louis vuitton Scarves |
hermes Scarves |
paul smith Scarves |
coach Scarves |
gucci Scarves |
chanel Scarves |
replica sunglass |

wholewatches.com |
canwatches.com |
idolreplica.com |
watcheshot.com |
watchessell.com |
GLT09alili1204
zhonglup0911
-------------------
replica watches |
replica rolex watches |
replica Breitling watches |

3:34 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

good post! thanks!
GLT09alili1204
There are many prada handbags |,gucci handbags | on line
prada handbags |
prada handbags |
nike shoes |nike shoes
wholesal shoes |wholesal shoes
wholesal nike shoes |wholesal nike shoes
replica sunglass | cheap sunglass
chanel handbags | chanel handbags
louis vuitton handbags | louis vuitton handbags
Gucci Handbags | Gucci Handbags
Wholesale scarves | Wholesale scarves
replica handbags | replica handbags
replica handbags | replica handbags
zhonglup0911
GLT09alili1204
Replica Watches | Replica Watches
replica omega watches | replica omega watches
swiss replica watches | swiss replica watches
swiss watches | swiss replica watches
Omega Watches | Omega Watches zhonglup11
Rolex Watches |
A Lange & Sohne Watches |
Audemars Piguet Watches |
Bell & Ross Watches |
Breguet Watches |
Breitling Watches |
Bvlgari Watches |
Baume mercier Watches |
Burberry Watches |
Cartier Watches |
Chanel Watches |
Carrera Watches |
Corum Watches |
Calvin Klein Watches |
Dolce & Gabbana Watches |
Franck Muller Watches |

3:35 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

ugg
cheap ugg boots
buy ugg boots
offering ugg
hot ugg
ugg boots
ugg classic
ugg sandals
ugg ultra boots
sitemap
bailey button ugg boots
nightfall ugg boots
sundance II ugg boots
ugg fluff flip flop
ugg stripe cable knit
ugg classic
classic tall ugg boots
short metallic ugg boots
tall metallic ugg boots
ugg classic argyle knit
ugg sandals
ugg amelie suede sandals
ugg coquette sandals
ugg dakota sandals
ugg morocco sandals
ugg tasmina braid sandals
ugg tasmina sandals
ugg ultra boots
ultra short ugg boots
kids ugg boots
ugg sundance grab bags
classic cardy ugg boots
classic mini ugg boots
classic short ugg boots
ugg classic crochet boots
ugg gypsy sandals
ugg halendi sandals
ultra tall ugg boots

2:20 AM 
Anonymous ugg boots sale said...

I agree with you, your saying is so good and usful for me. Thanks. Are you also like
ugg boots sale
ugg australia
uggs
It’s a meaningful and interesting topic. Thanks.

1:49 AM 
Anonymous bailey ugg boots said...

Bailey ugg boots
at a time when large heat has set off a winter 08/09 to Ewha.Outlines the warm wool winter fashion degree to wool crocheted wool
ugg classic
to join after the body does not stimulate your skin soft, soft comfort UP. Fashion can not without
UGG Bailey Button boots
presence in Winter.and ugg boots have many series.such as:
ugg nightfall

7:38 AM 
Anonymous jimmy choo handbags said...

cheap replica watches
replica DeWitt
DeWitt replica
Rolex Daytona watches
replica croum
jimmy choo handbags

1:00 AM 
Anonymous jimmy choo handbags said...

cheap replica watches
replica DeWitt
DeWitt replica
Rolex Daytona watches
replica croum
jimmy choo handbags

1:05 AM 
Anonymous jimmy choo handbags said...

cheap replica watches
replica DeWitt
DeWitt replica
Rolex Daytona watches
replica croum
jimmy choo handbags

1:13 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

cheap replica watches
Rolex Daytona replica
chopard watch for sale
Rolex Datejust II watches
Rolex Day Date watch for sale
cheap god shoes

1:26 AM 
Anonymous jimmy choo handbags said...

cheap replica watches
replica DeWitt
DeWitt replica
Rolex Daytona watches
replica croum
jimmy choo handbags

1:29 AM 
Anonymous ugg boots said...

Paragraph star UGG boots, many shops Amoy’s that some people go online to buy or Shopping Service, in a word, they are
very good look, take a look at the stars with their own, become a star is a small case! This the reason why
ugg boots sale are so popular now!Put on cotton boots is also moving up and
quiet,such as the ugg boots uk match with the pants.there is also a good dress with Miu leather. At the same time, necessary are gloves, ear muffs, snow ugg boots, sunglasses, scarf and so on, which you can pick the beautiful pieces of dress, no matter how technology, let us heavily armed first.so
now ugg boots sale in many shoes shop.there are many ugg boots you can choose in the
ugg boots uk shop!

3:05 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

hi , just loof buy cheap fake rolex and our best replica watches are very cheap fake swiss watches Replica Swiss watches replica Rolex
u can find on this sit cheap replica omega| cheap rolex|cheap replica rolexcheap replica|all good quality sone Cheap handbags can designer handbags and replica watch as fake watches Discount designer handbagshandbags Discount handbags SWISS WATCH
|cheap rolex|cheap replica rolexcheap replicabuy cheap fake rolexreplica Omega WatchesRolex Watch ReplicaReplica Rolex Watchesfake air kingRolex Explorerreplica rolex DateJustreplica watchesfake Omegareplica rolexRolex Day Date Wathcesfake rolexreplica rolex submarinerrolex air kingcheap rolex air kingRolex Day DateRolex Day Date replicafake Rolex Day Daterolex daytona replica

1:00 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

maple story mesos in the game you may or may not notice. I know vitality is very tempting in maple mesos. You may be feeling intelligence in mesos. You are going to be getting crab pincers which like buy maple story mesos, depending on which server you are on. cheap maple story mesos can help you get a high level in short time.

maple story mesos in the game you may or may not notice. I know vitality is very tempting in maple mesos. You may be feeling intelligence in mesos. You are going to be getting crab pincers which like buy maple story mesos, depending on which server you are on. cheap maple story mesos can help you get a high level in short time.

maple story mesos in the game you may or may not notice. I know vitality is very tempting in maple mesos. You may be feeling intelligence in mesos. You are going to be getting crab pincers which like buy maple story mesos, depending on which server you are on. cheap maple story mesos can help you get a high level in short time.

maple story mesos in the game you may or may not notice. I know vitality is very tempting in maple mesos. You may be feeling intelligence in mesos. You are going to be getting crab pincers which like buy maple story mesos, depending on which server you are on. cheap maple story mesos can help you get a high level in short time.

maple story mesos in the game you may or may not notice. I know vitality is very tempting in maple mesos. You may be feeling intelligence in mesos. You are going to be getting crab pincers which like buy maple story mesos, depending on which server you are on. cheap maple story mesos can help you get a high level in short time.

2:31 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

We guarantee we provide the cheapest ghd, ghd Hair Straighteners,ghd straighteners, ghd hair tools in the market and 100% Quality Guarantee.

1:36 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Thanks for your sharing,It's wonderful,Are you want to buy uggs?There are many good ugg boots, Welcome to our website You can buy something you like here.Thanks:
ugg boots sale;
ugg boots;
uggs;
ugg boots sale;
Bailey Button Ugg Boots;
classic tall ugg boots;
bailey button uggs ;
classic short ugg boots;
ugg boots bailey button;
bailey ugg boots;
The boots are great for everyday! You can just slip them on, with, out without socks and your ready to go. Just make sure that you weather proof them first!

2:20 AM 
Blogger lv said...

GLT10a01PENG12
replica handbags
replica watches
replica watches
Wholesale replica handbags
Replica Louis Vuitton
replica designer handbags
Louis Vuitton handbags
replica cartier watches
replica breitling watches
replica rolex watches
replica omega watches
Replica Handbags
replica rolex watches
cartier replica watches
replica watches
Omega replica watches
Chanel Handbags
Hermes Handbags
Gucci Handbags
Gucci replica handbags
gucci handbags,
Alexander Wang
replica prada
Prada handbags
Hermes handbags
Hermes Birkin
replica hermes
replica Bottega Veneta
Bottega Veneta handbags
replica burberry
Burberry handbags
Jimmy Choo replica handbags
Jimmy Choo handbags

3:45 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Knight Noah in the game you may or may not notice. I know vitality is very tempting in Knight Gold. You may be feeling intelligence in Buy Knight Noah. You are going to be getting crab pincers which like Cheap Knight Noah, depending on which server you are on. Knight Online Noah can help you get a high level in short time.

6:56 AM 
Blogger Edwin said...

Buy Kamagra
Earn Google
M65 Jacket
Viagra Cialis
Cheap Kamagra
Cheap Viagra
Cheap Cialis
Make Money on Google
M65 Field Jacket
Airline Dog Carrier
Airline Dog Carriers
Viagra Cialis
Earn Google
Airline Dog Carrier
Airline Dog Carriers
Airline Approved Dog Carriers
ED Hardy Wholesale
Copy DVD Software
How to Send Fax
14k Yellow Gold
Redneck Costume
14k Gold Heart
Tandem Baby Stroller

12:15 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Martial Heroes Gold and the swordsman in the game. Is it solo able in the MH Gold? It is not too bad, you should survive pretty well with buy Martial Heroes Gold if you equipment is up to date. Someone would like me who just reached IVI90 be able to survive more than one hit because buy MH Gold. The work of the reward system works without Martial Heroes money.

6:06 AM 
Anonymous air jordan 10 said...

More and more people began to collect jordan shoes. If you are Michael Jordan fans, you must have collection air jordans . If you want to buy the cheap jordan shoes,you can search the internet.Jordan is the hero of every individual mind. Of course, we are also very like the air jordan shoes .So you will like the air jordans,you will found the shoes make you become more and more beautiful.

2:22 AM 
Anonymous seo said...

This is great, thanks so much!

4:03 PM 
Anonymous ugg Bailey Button said...

0208sllrk The only word of Ashley is that he was in a Yankee prison for the last year of ugg classic cardy boots the war and a letter to Melanie telling her that he is on his way. One day, ugg Bailey Button he appears coming up the long road towards Tara. Melanie and Scarlett both rush to greet him, but Will stops Scarlett, ugg classic short boots saying, "Don't ruin the moment." ugg classic mini boots Scarlett reluctantly hangs back,ugg new arrival but is euphoric over Ashley's return.

2:24 AM 

Post a Comment

<< Home