Another World Is Possible

Tuesday, March 20, 2007

Whatever happened to equality as a Labour aim?

We published today the Left Economic Advisory Panel's (LEAP) alternative budget analysis, entitled "Whatever happened to equality?"

LEAP is a group which I founded and chair comprising socialist economists providing economic policy analysis and advice for the Left. It serves as our alternative to the Bank of England Advisory Committee but looks to the much longer term economic propects. LEAP publishes its Red Papers twice a year both prior to the autumn statement and prior to the budget. You can read and download LEAP's pre budget report on the Labour Representation Committee's website.

Ten years in power affords any government the opportunity of laying the foundations of the society it wishes to create. After ten years of New Labour Government and ten years of Gordon Brown's budgets it is valid and indeed timely to question the reality of the impact of the Chancellor's economic policies in shaping our community and the quality of life of our citizens.

The conclusion is that the most startling feature of our current society is the grotesque inequality which is disfiguring our community. Even the Financial Times today points out the difference that exists between the significant growth of GDP and the lack of matching growth in disposable income for many families suffering from low pay, long working hours, heavy tax burdens on the lower paid and rising housing costs, council tax and energy prices. Far from overcoming boom and bust what has been created over the last decade is an economy which is boom for some but bust for others.

In tomorrow's budget the Chancellor is hardly going to miss the opportunity prior a leadership election of making a great show of additional expenditure on education and some targetted benefit and expenditure increases but this will only be tinkering at the edges of inequality. Too many millions of our pensioners and of our children will still be going to bed in poverty tomorrow night because New Labour has refused to even accept inequality as an issue to be addressed over three terms of office.

Finally on a separate issue I spoke at the Stop the War assembly in Central Hall, Westminster today on the fourth anniversary of the invasion of Iraq, alongside Rose Gentle, a member of the military families who have lost relatives in Iraq. I thought what sadness and brutality Blair and Brown and all those who voted for this disgraceful war have brought into our lives. But it is not just the war for which this Government stands accused of inhumanity.

Before I spoke I had met Bob Holman, a Labour Party member for 43 years. Bob is an immensely respected community activist in Scotland, a writer, researcher and social policy expert. He showed me a report in today's Herald, the daily Scottish newspaper. It described how Mr Uddhav Bhandari, a father of two and an asylum seeker from Nepal, had doused himself in petrol and set himself alight earlier this month because he was facing a second legal hearing which could have resulted in him being forcibly returned to Nepal where his life was at risk. Mr Bhandari died yesterday.

The paper also reported that another asylum seeker, Mr Max Waku, who had fled from the Congo, was arrested from his home in a dawn raid. His children watched as their father was handcuffed and led out of the house to a waiting van. The children and their mother were then themselves removed one by one from their home and put into vans.

I find it hard to come to terms with the suffering that the Government is inflicting both at home and abroad.

That's why we need not just a change of leader but a wholesale change of the policies.

8 Comments:

Anonymous npm said...

Today's Budget :-

Sorry, was there a general election last week and I missed it?

Surely the Tories are now in government with income tax reduced and the lower band removed?

Have they swapped places? Am I in an alternative universe?

2:58 PM 
Anonymous Duncan McFarlane said...

While I'm not Brown's greatest fan surely abolishing the lowest rate of income tax benefits low earners and is a step towards equality?

I know much of the rest of the government's policy has the opposite effect but abolishing the 10p tax rate was the right thing to do in my opinion.

I agree this looks like an election budget - maybe it's a Labour leadership election budget since Brown's 15 points behind Cameron in the polls and some Labour MPs are getting nervous?

4:47 PM 
Anonymous npm said...

I'll check again Duncan, but as far as I am aware the lower rate has been abolished because the 10p tax rate will now be 20p! How can that help the lower paid?

And corporate tax dropped too!

On the bright side - this can only push more members onto John's campaign :-)

5:07 PM 
Anonymous Duncan McFarlane said...

You're right npm - sorry - i misunderstood when i first read the papers. He's abolished the lower tax rate for lower earners so they pay 20% income tax too - the only progressive piece of taxation he ever introduced he's reversed. Shameful.

http://business.guardian.co.uk/budget2007/story/0,,2039348,00.html

8:43 PM 
Anonymous h said...

on deportations to Congo; Iraq etc - it's like the Gestapo now and it's happening in our country; as I've said elsewhere on this site I've worked in this area and it wasn't as bad as this then and that was mostly under the Tories; there certainly were very few children in detention then and they didn't deport people to war zones, they did seem to have some concept of people's human rights although it did start to erode while I was there thinking about it with the attempts to introduce "white lists" of countries that were supposed t oeb safe to return people to but incuded countries like Sri Lanka which obviously weren't. The immigration officers at that time were opposed to the white list now it seems they don't need one anyway as they will deprt to anywhere! They also shortened the asylum interviews which meant those with a genuine case may not be heard but they told the staff it was to weed out the "bogus" applicants more quickly and people fell for it as it was less work for them. That was bad and part of the reasons I left and I cabn't believe they've got any staff left now especially in enforcement with the current immoral deportations and the staff will be at more risk of being attacked by desparate passengers; I've seen a notice up about not assaulting the staff at Heathrow which wasn't there when I was there.

I've always been haunted by the introduction to the paperback Anne Frank's diary in which they anaylse how soemthing as dreadful as the holocaust could happen and come to the frightening conclusion that it could happen again and I think that things just as dreadful are happening again round the world; some of it is not on such a big scale and so it continues because it is hidden such as sending people back to somehere like the Congo where torture and rape are unfortunatly commonplace and in other instances like Zimbabwe or Darfur it isn't hidden but we feel we still can't do anything about it.However if we hadn't scrapped the ethical foreign policy some thngs at least things might have been different

on the budget New Labour are saying that what they take away by cutting the 10p rate they will makw up in tax credits but I'm not sure I believe this; for one thing some Sure Start centres have been under threat and most of their plans to increase things like childcare don't come into effect until about 2009 if you look at the detail. One bit of good news I read today that people are taking on the big banks for charging over £30 even up to £100 for going over overdraft limits by small amounts when the OFT has ruled the charge should be £2.50-£4.50 yet they have charged people on very low incomes and benefits sending tehm deeper and deeper into debt. I'm going to try to get some of the charges I've paid back; aparently no-one has yet lost their case and the banks have paid up charges going back for the last six years!
Also if the banks refused to lend to students the govt would be forced to bring grants back in I've long thought!

Has anyone worked out the average age of troops losing their lives in Iraq?? It's probably not much above nineteen as in Vietnam....yesterday I was reading of two veterans from the Falkalnds who recently took thier own lives and which reminded me that as well as PTSD that the returing troops are at risk of it appears we can't even look after them in hospital properly which is barbaric really.Of course I wish they hadn't had to fight in the first place but they don't deserve this and they have apparently also been aboused by other patients who didn't agree with the war.

On housing a friend of mine has been offered a new kitchen and bathroom is they buy theirs - it's just bribery which will mean an even smaller supply of council housing as councils will have to upgrade the houses anyway.

Real redistribution needs completely different policies; a completely different but still LABOUR approach to what we have now if we are ever going to get true equality; we certainly aren't going to give in and say we need to LOSE an election first as someone wrote to the Guardain letters page today and a Miliband supporting type said in my ward meeting!

It's always better to stay in an dfight that hand it to your opponents on a plate, I rest my case!!!Do these people think a Tory government won't matter as we effectively have one already!! Words fail me! (It would be like New Lbaour but worse with public sector cuts, tax creditand childcare cuts etc etc... it dosn't bear thinking about).

The Patrick Wintoura article on the leadsrhip rules was sickeninglysycophantic to the idea of a Brown coronation as it began but then had to admit that there would almost certainly eb an election!

Bring it on then, as John says.

12:10 AM 
Blogger steffaction said...

i was at the StWC Assembly, and I felt you spoke well. What was amusing was Meacher's reception, particularly Benn glowering at him. John Rees' speech was fantastic, although, toward the end, i got speaker fatigue.

1:14 AM 
Blogger grimupnorth said...

See my blog for views on Brown's "Robin Hood in reverse" Budget . If Meacher got a bad reception, I just hope he is getting the message.......how can he not?

12:24 PM 
Anonymous Duncan McFarlane said...

Our government's treatment of asylum seekers is shameful. How can they say they judge each case on its merits and then operate a quota for how many people are to be deported each year?

Here's my take on the budget -
http://www.duncanmcfarlane.org/Budget_Response_Mar07/

or http://inplaceoffear.blogspot.com/

10:46 AM 

Post a Comment

<< Home